← Back to Past Picks
LOST economics
Will US nonfarm payrolls for March 2026 be above 90K?
The Setup
The market asks if the US economy added more than 90,000 jobs in March 2026. With consensus estimates hovering around 60,000 following a shocking 92,000 job loss in February, traders are weighing a mechanical rebound in healthcare against a structural slowdown. The release is scheduled for tomorrow, April 3, making this a pure play on the upcoming BLS print.
A 31,000-job boost from returning striking workers will be entirely offset by a 30,000-job drag from unpaid DHS employees, leaving the headline print anchored to a weak 60,000 consensus.
Market
70c
Our Estimate
65-85c
Edge
+5c
Bull Case
The primary headwind for the March report is the ongoing partial government shutdown affecting the Department of Homeland Security. Because over 100,000 DHS employees worked without pay during the BLS reference week, strict establishment survey methodology dictates they will be excluded from the payrolls. This creates an estimated 25,000 to 30,000 mechanical drag on government employment, effectively neutralizing any positive sector rebounds.
Professional consensus remains firmly anchored below the 90,000 threshold, with median estimates clustered between 55,000 and 65,000. To resolve YES, the print must beat consensus by roughly 30,000 jobs in an environment where macroeconomic indicators show cooling labor demand. The February JOLTS report highlighted this cooling, with the hires rate falling to 3.1%—matching the pandemic low of April 2020.
Furthermore, hiring breadth is extremely narrow. While the headline ADP number beat expectations, its internal composition revealed that medium and large businesses actually shed jobs in March. With core sectors like trade, transportation, and manufacturing actively contracting, the private sector lacks the broad-based growth necessary to offset the federal payroll drag and push the total figure above 90,000.
Bear Case
The strongest argument against our NO recommendation rests on a mechanical rebound from February's dismal data. Approximately 31,000 healthcare workers who were on strike during the February survey period returned to work in March. This provides a guaranteed baseline addition to the headline number, meaning the underlying economy only needs to generate roughly 60,000 jobs to clear the threshold.
High-frequency labor data also shows surprising resilience on the firing side. Initial jobless claims for late March fell to 210,000, while continuing claims dropped to a 10-month low of 1.819 million. This lack of layoff pressure provides a stable floor for the NFP print, increasing the probability of an upside surprise.
Finally, the March ADP National Employment Report beat expectations, printing at 62,000 against a 40,000 consensus. If the BLS establishment survey captures similar resilience, particularly the 112,000 jobs added by small businesses in the ADP data, a surprise beat into the low six figures remains statistically plausible.
What Could Go Wrong
IF the BLS applies a large positive seasonal adjustment or birth-death model addition to account for small business creation, THEN the headline NFP could easily spike above 90,000 despite weak corporate hiring.
IF the BLS treats the unpaid DHS workers differently than expected (e.g., counting them due to state-level interventions or fee-based accounts), THEN the anticipated 30,000 government payroll drag will not materialize, removing the primary ceiling on the headline number.
Get picks like this daily
Full analysis delivered to your inbox every morning at 7:00 a.m. ET.
Start Free Trial