← Back to Past Picks
WON politics

Will the President's approval rating be above 42.8 according to RealClearPolitics? — 0 or above

The Setup

The market asks if President Trump's RealClearPolitics job approval average will exceed 42.8% by April 24, 2026. With the current average sitting around 41.4% and recent polling dragged down by geopolitical and economic headwinds, traders are betting on whether a mathematically improbable 1.4-point surge can occur in just six days.

With recent polls from Quinnipiac and CNN dragging Trump's approval into the mid-30s, a 1.4-point RCP average spike in six days is mathematically near-impossible.

Market
91c
Our Estimate
92-99c
Edge
+5c

Bull Case

The mathematical reality of the RealClearPolitics average makes a 1.4-point jump in six days nearly impossible under current conditions. The average currently sits around 41.4%. Because the average typically includes 5 to 10 recent polls, moving the aggregate by 1.4 points requires any new polls added to be significantly higher than the ones they replace, likely in the 46 to 48% range. However, recent polling data shows the exact opposite trend. High-quality surveys from Quinnipiac (38%), CNN (35%), and YouGov (37%) are coming in well below the current average. As these sub-40% polls replace older data in the RCP calculation, they will exert downward pressure, making it mathematically destined for the average to decline rather than rise toward the 42.8% threshold. Furthermore, the fundamental drivers of these low approval ratings are entrenched. The ongoing military conflict with Iran and the resulting spike in domestic gas prices with Brent crude hitting $107 have severely damaged the administration's standing. With 65% of voters blaming the President directly for the pain at the pump, there is no immediate catalyst to generate the sudden surge in public approval required to hit 42.8%.

Bear Case

For the market to resolve YES, the RealClearPolitics average would need to experience a sudden, sharp upward revision. This could theoretically happen if several older, low-water mark polls drop out of the rolling average window simultaneously and are replaced by new polls from right-leaning pollsters like Rasmussen or Napolitan showing approval in the mid-to-high 40s. Additionally, a major positive catalyst could trigger a rapid shift in public sentiment. If the recent ceasefire in the Iran conflict leads to a sudden drop in gas prices, pollsters might capture a delayed rally 'round the flag effect. Flash polls reflecting this optimism could theoretically push the average higher if RCP editors aggressively include them. Finally, the specific methodology of the RealClearPolitics average introduces a degree of unpredictability. RCP editors have discretion over which polls to include and when to drop older surveys. If they decide to cycle out several recent sub-40% polls, the average could artificially jump higher even without a massive influx of new, positive data.

What Could Go Wrong

IF RealClearPolitics abruptly changes its methodology or the specific pollsters it includes by dropping several mainstream polls and only including right-leaning pollsters, THEN the average could artificially spike above 42.8%. IF a sudden, positive resolution to the Iran conflict triggers an immediate rally 'round the flag effect captured by daily tracking polls, THEN the average could spike before the April 24 deadline.

Get picks like this daily

Full analysis delivered to your inbox every morning at 7:00 a.m. ET.

Start Free Trial