← Back to Past Picks
LOST economics
Will above 40000 jobs be added in February 2026? — 40,000
The Setup
The market is pricing a 60% chance that the US economy added more than 40,000 jobs in February 2026, a surprisingly low probability given the 130,000 added in January. While the Kaiser Permanente strike (31k workers) creates a known drag, the robust ADP report (+63k) suggests the private sector has enough momentum to clear this low hurdle. The trade is a bet that the 'official' BLS count will continue its recent trend of outperforming private payroll data.
ADP's 63k print yesterday beat the 48k consensus, signaling private sector strength that should override the 31k Kaiser strike drag. With the market pricing a coin flip, the 40k threshold is a buy.
Market
60c
Our Estimate
60-80c
Edge
+10c
Bull Case
The strongest signal for a YES outcome is the March 4 ADP National Employment Report, which showed private sector gains of 63,000 jobs—beating the consensus forecast of 48,000 and marking the best performance since July 2025. Historically, when ADP beats expectations, the BLS Nonfarm Payrolls (NFP) print tends to follow suit or exceed it, particularly in the current environment where NFP has consistently run hotter than ADP (e.g., January NFP was +130k vs. ADP +11k). Even if we subtract the full impact of the Kaiser Permanente strike (approx. 31,000 workers), the ADP baseline of 63,000 leaves a net positive of 32,000 before accounting for any government hiring or the structural 'NFP premium' seen in recent months.
Furthermore, the strike impact is likely mitigated by replacement workers. Reports from Kaiser Permanente indicate that 'more than 40% of nurses and pharmacists' returned to work during the strike, and contingency personnel were deployed. If only half of the 31,000 striking workers are subtracted from the payroll count during the survey week, the drag reduces to ~15,000. Combined with the consensus forecast of 59,000 (Trading Economics) to 70,000 (Morningstar), the arithmetic heavily favors a print above the low 40,000 bar.
Bear Case
The bear case hinges on a 'perfect storm' of technical drags: a major strike, government contraction, and a statistical payback for January's outlier strength. BofA Securities (forecast: 35,000) and Wells Fargo (forecast: 25,000) both cite the Kaiser Permanente strike and the unwinding of the birth/death model adjustment as key reasons for a sub-40k print. If the BLS strictly counts all 31,000 striking workers as zero (unpaid during the survey week of Feb 8-14), and federal government payrolls continue their January trend of decline (-34k), the headline number could easily collapse to the 20k-30k range.
Additionally, the divergence between ADP and NFP is a mean-reversion risk. The massive 119k gap in January (NFP 130k vs ADP 11k) is statistically unsustainable. If the BLS data realigns with the weaker ADP trend, and we simultaneously subtract the strike impact, the 'underlying' growth could be revealed as near-zero. The 'low-hire, low-fire' dynamic noted by Nationwide economists suggests stall speed, where a single negative shock (like the strike) pushes the net add below the 40,000 threshold.
What Could Go Wrong
IF the BLS birth/death model adjustment unwinds aggressively (subtracting ~50k phantom jobs added in Jan), THEN the headline number could drop below 40k regardless of the strike status.
IF the Kaiser Permanente strike involved strict 'no pay' enforcement for all 31,000 union members during the entire survey week (Feb 8-14), AND replacement workers were classified as contractors rather than employees, THEN the deduction from the headline number will be the full 31k, likely pushing the total below 40k.
Get picks like this daily
Full analysis delivered to your inbox every morning at 7:00 a.m. ET.
Start Free Trial