Reminders of Him Rotten Tomatoes score? — Above 55

The film currently maintains a 56% critic score on Rotten Tomatoes as of the morning of March 16, 2026, according to reports from the Associated Press and The Independent. This score has shown significant stability, holding at the 56% mark since Sunday afternoon despite the addition of late-weekend reviews. Unlike previous Colleen Hoover adaptations, Reminders of Him benefited from the direction of Vanessa Caswill, whose previous romance film, Love at First Sight (2023), earned a 75% fresh rating, establishing a higher quality floor for this production. Critical reception has been bolstered by the casting of Maika Monroe, a frequent critic favorite known for her work in Longlegs and It Follows. Even mixed reviews from outlets like The Guardian (March 11, 2026) and Variety (March 13, 2026) have praised the lead performances and the film's emotional sincerity, which often prevents the score from bottoming out into the sub-30% range seen by 2025's Regretting You. With only 90 minutes remaining until the market resolution, the volume of new reviews typically slows to a trickle on Monday mornings, making a two-point drop highly unlikely.

The film's critical trajectory has been consistently downward since its initial reviews were indexed. Forbes reported a 63% score on Thursday, March 13, which fell to 59% by Friday evening and finally to 56% by Sunday. This negative momentum suggests that as more reviews from smaller, non-top critics are added, the consensus is shifting toward the rotten side of the spectrum. A single additional rotten review could potentially drop the score to 55%, which would result in a No resolution for this market. Prominent critics from Vulture (March 14, 2026) and Slant Magazine (March 13, 2026) have issued scathing reviews, labeling the film as bloodless and contrived. These reviews often influence late-reporting critics who may share a similar distaste for the Colleen Hoover brand of melodrama. If a final batch of reviews from metropolitan dailies or specialized film sites is uploaded before the 10:00 AM ET deadline, the razor-thin one-point cushion above the 55 threshold could easily vanish.