← Back to Past Picks
WON culture
Hoppers Rotten Tomatoes score? — Above 95
The Setup
The market is betting on whether Pixar's latest original feature, Hoppers, can join the elite '95+ club' of animated masterpieces. Traders are currently pricing this at 59%, showing high optimism for director Daniel Chong's debut. This is a critical test of whether Pixar has regained its 'prestige' era consistency after a decade of fluctuating scores.
Only 17% of Pixar's original films in the last decade have cleared the 95% hurdle, yet the market is pricing a 59% chance for Hoppers to join that elite tier.
Market
41c
Our Estimate
55-75c
Edge
+24c
Bull Case
The creative pedigree of director Daniel Chong provides a high floor for critical reception. Chong's previous work on We Bare Bears: The Movie (2020) maintained a 100% Rotten Tomatoes score, demonstrating a comedic sensibility that resonates with critics. Early footage shown at D23 in August 2024 was described by trade press as a return to Pixar's high-concept, idiosyncratic roots, which historically perform better with critics than the studio's more conventional sequels.
Original Pixar films that lean into 'weird' or culturally specific themes, such as Turning Red (2022) and Soul (2020), both reached the 95% threshold. If Hoppers captures the same level of inventive storytelling, it only needs a slight edge to push into the 96%+ range. The voice cast, led by Jon Hamm and Bobby Moynihan, suggests a sophisticated comedic tone that often appeals to the older demographic of the Critics Choice and major guild reviewers who populate the Tomatometer.
Bear Case
The 95% threshold is an elite barrier that even Pixar's most successful recent films have failed to cross. Inside Out 2 (2024), despite being a massive critical and commercial success, settled at 91%. Over the last decade, only two Pixar films—Toy Story 4 (97%) and Coco (97%)—have finished above 95%. The base rate for original Pixar properties hitting this mark is approximately 17%, making the current market price of 59% look like a significant over-correction based on brand sentiment rather than historical performance.
As the review count increases toward the March 9 resolution date, scores almost universally drift downward. A film starting at 98% with 30 reviews frequently drops to 93-94% once the full pool of 250+ critics weighs in. Given that Hoppers is a body-swap comedy involving a robotic beaver, it risks being perceived as 'minor Pixar' or too juvenile by a segment of critics, similar to Luca (91%) or Onward (88%), neither of which came close to the 96% required for a Yes resolution.
What Could Go Wrong
IF the review embargo remains in place until March 5 or 6, THEN the total review count on March 9 may be low enough (under 80) to allow a high initial score to persist without the typical downward drift.
IF the film's emotional core regarding the animal kingdom resonates as strongly as the environmental themes in WALL-E (95%), THEN it could achieve the near-universal acclaim necessary to defy the 17% base rate.
Get picks like this daily
Full analysis delivered to your inbox every morning at 7:00 a.m. ET.
Start Free Trial